Love the Unexpected

"She's so close by Jay! She just moved in here, I'm sure the last thing she wants to hear is her brother 'getting it on' with his girlfriend. Maybe we should finish up quick." Jen whispers

"Don't worry, we've got a fan on. I doubt she can hear you." I tried to convince her.

"Oh whatever!" Jen smacked at my chest playfully. "You just don't want to quit!"

"Yeah...so?" I looked down at her with a shit-eaten grin

"What the hell has gotten into you? You're so damned horny tonight." Jen kind of shook her head and moaned at the same time, as I began to slowly fuck her again.

"You just look especially beautiful today, that's all. I can't help myself."

"You always seem to know what to say, don't you?" Jen reaches up and kisses me. She switched positions with me, and began to ride my cock up and down.

She really was stunning tonight. But that is only half the reason I was as worked up as I was, even if I didn't want to admit it. Jen continued to ride my cock hard, pounding down on me fast and hard each time. The sound of our bodies banging into one another actually made me think twice about whether Amanda could hear us. I was enjoying myself all too much to worry much about it though.

After a few minutes of this, I was ready to cum. I asked Jen where she wanted it, and she replied "go inside of me." That always turned her on, despite my being worried. She trusted in her birth control, so I always went along with her wishes. I came harder than I ever had before inside of her lovely pussy.

She rolled over off of my cock slowly, so as not to hurt. I enjoyed looking at her lying next to me just glowing from the sex we just had. Jen was still playing with her pussy slightly, running my cum across her lips and giggling.

We cleaned up quickly before going to sleep. Both of us slept naked and half on top of one another. I loved Jen too much.

That morning Jen and I woke up early. Jen had to be to work; she had a position as a secretary for a private medical office. It kept her too damned busy sometimes in my opinion. We showered together and I saw her off in the morning, then I got dressed for my day. My work was rather easy in comparison to most people. All I had to do was meet with a few kids to tutor them for a few hours. I attempted to find Amanda to tell her where I was going before I left, but she was nowhere to be found. I didn't worry myself and left to be about my business.

Hours later I arrived back home. "Amanda! Yo, are you home?"

Not even thirty seconds later I came across Amanda lying on the living room couch. There wouldn't be anything unusual about this if not for the fact that she was only wearing a tiny black tank top and curiously these pink, lacey form-fitting panties. She was on her stomach reading some sort of magazine. Her legs were so smooth that it was maddening. Watching her move those sexy legs up and down was taunting. I was shocked to see her lounging around the house wearing so little. And I was even more surprised to hear that her reaction to my being home was calm and normal.

"Hey Jay. How was work? You weren't gone too long." She said

"It was fine Amanda. Easy as usual." I struggled to find words, but I didn't want to make this seem like an issue. After all, this was her home too now. "Just had to help some kids with sentence structure today."

"That's good. You have got to hook me up with one of these cushy tutoring positions once I get done with this high school crap."

"Oh for sure. I think you'd probably be even better at it than I am. You were always the smart one."

"Oh whatever! I'm smart sure, but you were almost 'Mr. Valedictorian.' If it weren't for auto shop, the mighty Jay might have delivered a wordy speech at his graduation." She always did like to pick on me.

"Yeah, yeah. I know how to change my own oil now I'll have you know!"

"Uh...did Jen teach you?" she sunk her nails in even more with the jokes.

"Yeah actually. Geez, you are Ms. Know-it-all today!" I exclaimed as I walked to a recliner sitting near the couch Amanda was lying upon and took a seat.

"I put a load of laundry in by the way. It'll be done in a few. I just put yours and Jen's in with mine."

"Jen's? I don't think she left any clothes over here? That's cool though, I appreciate it."

"Well, Jen just had some cute red boy shorts on your floor. I hope you don't mind me poking around in your room."

My face turned red, but I tried to hide my embarrassment. "N-no...that ain't a problem. Heh, you probably think Jen and I are slobs if you looked in my room though. Sorry about that."

"No reason to be sorry Jay. You and Jen are great together. Apparently you had a great night last night too. I washed the sheets for you, and made the bed. I'll take thanks in the form of gift cards or more good meals like last night's. That chicken parmesan was awesome." She chortled as she gave me a grin.

"So...I won't beat around the bush. You heard Jen and I last night didn't you?"

"Yeah. I wouldn't be surprised if the neighbors did too. You guys were going at it!"

Amanda was being especially frank about the situation, and it made my face turn an even deeper shade of red. "Listen, I'm sorry. I probably should have been a little more discreet being that I have a roommate now. It won't happen again. I don't want to scare you off, or freak you out."

"It doesn't freak me out. I think it's nice." Amanda got off the couch and stood in front of my chair for a moment. She then sat on the arm of the chair and swung her legs so that they'd rest atop my lap.

"Well, I'm glad it didn't freak you out then."

"It's a beautiful thing. I wish I had someone I loved that much. The sex had to be great." She was obviously prodding for more information.

"We do have great sex, but are you sure you want to talk about this with your brother?" I asked her

"Why not? I always shared everything with you. You should be open with me!" she smacked my right arm softly

"Fine. I will be."

"I haven't had the chance to be with many guys yet. So I might be a little envious of you. Mother wasn't the type to let me date, so I had to do it in secret most of the time. I'm not very experienced."

"Well you'd better not be! You're my little sister, and you'll remain a virgin until marriage!" She knew I was joking as I gave her my 'impression of my father' face.

"A little too late for that. But not super late. I've only been with one guy. And he was clumsy and stumbled a lot. Not the best experience." She started to kind of rub her legs together; making the smooth skin on both legs softly slide along mine.

"If I told you I was surprised that you've been with a guy, I'd be lying. You're an absolutely beautiful girl Amanda. It was bound to happen. Probably all the guys in your school dream about you." I gave her the elbow nudge

"Maybe they do. But I'm not interested in any of them. I have one guy I like, but I don't wanna talk about it yet. I just want to know what it's like when you meet that certain someone that you just mesh with, you know?"

"It's great. When you meet the right person everything just feels right. Maybe not right away, but once you get comfortable and all of those walls you've been building come down, you can just be so open and intimate with that one person. It's a beautiful thing."

Amanda obviously liked my answer. Her eyebrows rose, and she nodded her head in approval. "Are you going to marry Jen?"

"I think so. I haven't bought a ring yet, but I'm saving up. I love her to death." I did not hesitate to tell her this.

Amanda leaned over to me and kissed me on the cheek in a cartoon fashion. "I'm very proud of you. Just keep a guest room available for me for a few years. I'd rather live with you guys than in a dorm. I love it here!"

I patted her on the thigh. "You'll always have a place with Jen and I if you want."

"Plus I get to hear entertainment every night! It's better than porn!" at that line, she bit her bottom lip. It was so erotic, but I fought to hold back those thoughts.

"Speaking of Jen...she'll be home soon. She called me from work before you got here. I'm going out to dinner with her tonight. It's a girl's night out, so you can't come! I'm gonna get ready to go...you should go out with your buddies tonight or something."

She leapt off of the arm of the recliner and began to walk up stairs. As she turned she wiggled her ass cutely. I could not help but watch her all while she was walking up the stairs.

Amanda looked so cute and sexy as she walked away, that it made my cock ache. I wasn't dumb enough not to know that she was teasing me. But part of me didn't want to believe it. For her to act like that around her own brother...it was so out of character for her. She was so adorable in those pink panties though, and I couldn't stop thinking about them. What was I going to do about this?

I decided to stop fretting over it, and to just deal with it as it came. I called a few guy friends of mine and decided to go to a local sports pub for drinks. They were people I knew since high school for the most part, so it was a blast just reminiscing about days gone by. We went on and on about the most inane shit for hours, but it was made funnier by the fact that we were drinking.

I received a text from Jen around 8:00PM that said she wasn't going to be staying at my place that night. She said something came up, and that she'd dropped Amanda back off at the house. Jen also noted that she'd try to call me later that night, and that she was thinking about our passionate night of sex from before. Her text message aroused me beyond belief just by bringing up the memory of what we had done. It was painful to know that there wouldn't be a repeat performance waiting for me at home. I said my goodbyes to the friends to make my way back.

I arrived back home at only 9:00PM, but the house was strangely dark. No lights were on. I yelled out for Amanda to see if she was still about. "Hey Amanda, I'm back home? What came up with Jen anyways?"

There was no response. The house was fairly quiet, at least until I started walking up the stairs towards my bedroom. As I got further up the steps, I began to hear moaning. The only person home had to be Amanda. As soon as those sounds hit my eardrums my cock jumped in my pants. I knew it was bad to be thinking those sort of thoughts, but damn if I could help it. I tried to avoid the situation, so I decided to sneak past Amanda's room and bolt into mine to change my clothes. That plan backfired when I found her lying atop my bed.

Amanda hadn't heard me come in yet. Her eyes were closed, and her hands deep down her tight little pink panties. The straps to her tank top were disheveled and drooping over his shoulders only slightly. You could tell she had no bra on either, as her erect nipples surfaced.

She looked stunning I couldn't lie about that. Amanda was such a beautiful girl that I couldn't help but have my eyes be drawn towards this sight. My cock immediately hardened, and I'm sure my jaw dropped. I tried to slip back out of the door to hide, but Amanda finally opened her eyes and noticed me.

"Jay!" Amanda had a few gasps, and pulled her hand out of her panties. She sat up on the bed slightly, leaning back on her elbows. She seemed flustered for a second, but then she gathered herself.

"Were you just going to stand there and watch me? Come on, you could have said something!" Amanda said

"Whoa, I'm sorry. I didn't expect you to be in my room. Don't worry about this. We...can just pretend like I saw nothing..." I said as I tried to avert my eyes.

"And what did you see exactly?" Amanda said in a semi-childish tone, almost to showcase her being playful on the subject.

"I...I saw my beautiful little sister relieving some stress. That's all. We all do it." I assured her. I didn't want her to be embarrassed.

"You're right, we do. I was doing this a lot last night actually." She giggled as she admitted

"Better than watching porn, right?" I tried to force a laugh

"You'd better believe it Jay." Amanda kind of bit the right side of her lip, and placed her hand back down her panties. I was dumbfounded and incredibly turned on.

"So Jay since you saw me I have to know, did you like what you saw?" she asked as she continues to rub herself inside of her panties.

"Listen, you're my sister. This isn't right." I plead with her.

"Of course it's right! I've wanted this for so long! How can you be so dense? We're both adults here. I know you like this Jay. I can tell just by looking at the bulge in your pants."

My face turned a deep shade of red as I couldn't help but look at her. She was so beautiful, and truth be told I wanted her more than anything else in the world at that moment. But what was I to do?

"Amanda, I have a girlfriend and I'm not sure I'm comfortable with this. You're absolutely beautiful but I...just can't okay?"

"I'll share you with Jen, I don't care. I spoke with her tonight you know." Amanda stopped her rubbing, and looked at me seriously.

"Oh really?" I was actually curious for her to continue with this.

"She's a great girl Jay. I absolutely love her too. And I want you guys to be together. You're meant to be...but so are we." At this point it sounded like she was begging for me to listen to her words.

"How could you say that? You know I love you, but what am I supposed to do here dammit!?"

"I have loved you forever. You were my first crush, and the only person I have ever wanted. "But what about Jen then? What would she think?"

"I admitted my true feelings to Jen. I told her how I've wanted you all this time. Jay, she said that she knows how much you love her. She wants to marry you Jay, to have your children. But she also knows about the chemistry between you and I! She told me that what you and I do will not change yours and hers relationship!"

I couldn't believe it. She told Jen all of this...and she said that she was fine with it? It was almost too good to be true. But was I horrible for thinking it to be good. I was torn.

"I just need this. It can't be wrong if we both want it all right? This is all I've thought about in my dreams for years." Amanda said with a longing moan

"I-I...I've had dreams about you too. No! Wait, I shouldn't have said that. We can't."

"Just because you think it's supposed to be wrong, you'd deny me? Please don't Jay. Just let me have my moment, this once. Then you can be the judge on where it can go from there."

I had trouble continuing to resist. I tried to look away, but Amanda stood to her feet and removed her tank top. Her perky beasts were exposed to the cool air. Amanda's puffy pink nipples made my cock throb.

She walks up to me and kissed me on the lips. It was a passionate closed mouth kiss, the kind that you could tell she'd been putting a lot of thought into for a while. I could not help but kiss her back. We stood there kissing for several minutes. I then knew I'd crossed the point of no return. My tongue entwined with hers, passionately reaching out to one another.

I moved on to grabbing her breasts. She yelped as soon as I grabbed them, showing me how horny she really was. They were aching for attention. I caressed them and squeezed them with care, massaging her nipples just a tad before beginning to suck on them. She cooed contently.

When Amanda had enough of her tits being shown attention she slid her panties down to her ankles. My mouth watered as I stared down at her lovely mound. It was absolutely perfectly formed. Pink lips, and she even shaved her area to have only a landing strip above the clit. I was in love right off the bat.

I threw her onto the bed and went to town eating her pussy. I rotated my tongue around her labia clockwise, and rubber her clit with my thumb. She moaned so loudly during this that it brought music to my ears. Her musky scent and taste was marvelous, and I lapped up her wet pussy.Amanda had several small orgasms during this time, and every time she had one she would press her thighs hard up against my temples. I made her nearly crawl out of her skin when I lightly licked around the rim of her asshole. She jumped and screamed "Jay!" Eventually Amanda stopped me as she was hungering to touch me as well.

Amanda made me stand to my feet as she unbuttoned the fly of my jeans, and dug into my boxer shorts. She started stroking my cock, but got tired of the fabric being partially in her way. She forcefully shoved my pants down to my ankles, and I aided her by kicking them off. I threw my boxers across the room, and let her do her thing.

She stood and then turned to push me on the bed. Amanda then leapt on top of the bed and slowly but surely squatted down on my face. She grinded her pussy against my nose to entice me, and then leaned over to suck my cock. I began to eat her pussy once more, licking up and down the slit, and just taking in all of the loveliness of her mound. She licked the tip of my cock like a lollipop as I did so, and eventually she went for broke. She plunged her mouth onto my dick, and actually managed to shove nearly the whole thing into her mouth. She stumbled for a second; nearly gagging before finding the right amount she could put in and comfortably suck me off.

She was surprisingly good at sucking dick for an inexperienced girl. All the while I licked her pussy, and even her asshole when she was in a good enough position. I found it incredibly cute how she'd nearly jump every time I did that. I was getting too close to orgasm though, and didn't want her to finish me off yet. I needed to fuck her. I had to be inside her vagina.

It was now finally time. I asked her if she really wanted to do this, and she said she did. Amanda positioned her ass up in the air, spreading wide and presenting her pussy to me like a gift. I treated it like the best gift I ever received, as I carefully teased the tip of my dick against her pussy lips. She yelled for me to stick it in, moaning in pleasure all the while. I poked the head of my dick inside of her, and realized that she was very tight. Probably the tightest pussy I will ever fuck in my life. I slid the cock in slow until a majority of it was inside of her. She grabbed a nearby pillow and shoved her face into it, biting it. I slowly humped her, and her vagina was wet and quivering. Soon enough she rose her head from the pillow and screamed for me to go harder.

I obliged and began to take the normal hard pace I go with Jen. I pounded Amanda's vag hard and fast, making my balls slap up against her ass ferociously. She was so tight that I could barely keep from Cumming within the first few minutes. Willpower prevailed and I kept going, but I could tell I wasn't lasting long.

I told her to reach back and rub her clit with her hand. I said I wanted her to come hard for me. It didn't take much longer than a few more minutes of steady pounding and rubbing to make her gush out a strong orgasm, the strongest she'd ever experienced! I pulled out of her slowly, as her body bounced up and down. She finally laid down flat on the bed, but still writhing in pleasure from her orgasm.

I was at my threshold. I was going to come hard any second now, so I just told her to get ready. I stroked myself off the last little bit and didn't even have time to ask her where she wanted it. I shot my load onto her tight little asshole, and then just collapsed next to her.

As we were lying there on the bed, she turned over onto her back and looked me in the eyes. She had the hugest grin on her face that I had ever seen.

"I told you Jay! I knew you wanted it! Thank you for letting me finally have what I've wanted all this time." She was glowing, much like Jen was after we had our night of passion.

"I love you Amanda. This was one of the best nights of my life. I don't know where we go from here. Jen...well..." I stumbled on my words, so I just began to stroke Amanda's beautiful black hair.