All Comments on 'Reap as ye sow'

by matriarch

Sort by:
  • 13 Comments
jd4georgejd4georgeover 19 years ago
I liked the poem...

...though I don't like the title. Titles (especially here) are the first thing a reader sees. Though in context with the poem, when I first read the title, my reaction was "oh no... same old, same old". I almost didn't read it.

What about a more oblique title, such as "As the Elders Tell"?

AnonymousAnonymousover 19 years ago
A twist with the title

This was a good read. I cheated and looked at Geo's

comment, I agree with him. I almost didn't read it either,

glad I did.

RebeccaLeahRebeccaLeahover 19 years ago
Lovely

I like the title, though it might be a bit confusing.

Very touching.

*hugs*

irishcatsmeowirishcatsmeowover 19 years ago
Pride....

This poem speaks of pride and contentment...in yourself and in your sons. What greater harvest is there than this? Great way of telling your story.

doormousedoormouseover 19 years ago
My fave so far!!

"The tall, strong, full grown stalks of my sowing,

My children, my sons,

My corn, my harvest."

This alone speaks volumes!!

Brilliant job Mat!! Loved it (and not said just as a friend)

;-)

annaswirlsannaswirlsover 19 years ago
art of the craft

nice job! Thanks for playing :)

I enjoyed the use of metaphor to convey your message and the sparse language. I would love to chat with you so I can ask some questions about this-- let me know if you would like to do that--

no thermo

PatCarringtonPatCarringtonover 19 years ago
i agree with the first comment

very nice poem / very bad title / if it were not a part of the challenge, i would have passed it over because of the title alone / after reading, that would have been an obvious error /

BelegonBelegonover 19 years ago
poetry titles...

...are so damn hard! I always struggle with them myself. That lil bit o' selfishness aside, I really like your effort Mat!

herecomestherainherecomestherainover 19 years ago
I can almost see those sons...

Lovely images Mat, succinct, concise and precise. The love shows through. :)

ABSTRUSEABSTRUSEover 19 years ago
Beautiful

This touched my soul, I have to go hug my kids now.

Syndra LynnSyndra Lynnover 19 years ago
this is beyond good

wonderful. thanks

BlackShanglanBlackShanglanabout 19 years ago
Beautiful work

I love the concrete, tactile simplicity of the final stanza. Ripe, strong, and a pleasure to read. Very nice work, Mat.

Bridget69Bridget69about 19 years ago
Lovely.

Briefly yet vividly describes the pride which accompanies accomplished nurturing.

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous