Mistaken Identity

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

“Really?” I asked, trying to recall just what I had done.

“Oh yeah! If the place hadn’t been so dam crowded, I would have probably fucked you right there on the bar,” she said, taking a generous step towards me. “So, tell me what your nasty mind is up to tonight, Honey,” she asked, brushing back her long, curly brunette locks.

Laying her hands on my shoulders, she let them ease down my chest and unbuttoned my blouse. “See my husband and I play these fantasy games…” I started, as she undid another button.

“Go on, I’m listening,” she whispered, staring into my eyes.

“Well, up until last week, these fantasies never actually involved other people,” I continued, as she unbuttoned the rest and pulled my blouse out of my skirt.

“OK, I see. Tell me more,” urged Jennifer, taking my blouse off.

The sweet young fragrance of her perfume filled my senses, as she leaned over and kissed my bare neck and unhooked my bra. I tried hard to catch my breath, as she seductively pulled my bra off and raised one of my melons to her mouth. As she licked and sucked my nipples, I pulled back.

“Uh, no offense, but I’m not really into other women,” I stated, and criss-crossed my arms to cover my bare chest.

“I know. Neither am I. Its just that Josh said your tits tasted so good, I had to try them for myself,” she said, lowering herself to her knees.

“He said that? God, he’s such a cute stud. Imagine him liking the taste of old lady tits?” I thought, as Jennifer ran her hands under my skirt.

Suddenly, she ripped down my panties, raised my skirt and buried her face in my pussy. Her talented tongue found my g-spot immediately. Losing all control, I fell back against the washbasin and let her bring me to a quick orgasm.

“OH GOD, OH GOD, OH GODDDD!” I yelled, as Jennifer sucked my fresh juices.

Frozen in disbelief, I watched foxy Jennifer scoop up my panties and bra and stick them in my purse. She kissed me full on the mouth, letting me taste my own cum. As quickly as she had seduced me, she fixed my skirt and returned my blouse.

“Now, what were you saying about fantasies?” She asked smiling.

“Oh yeah!” I said, shaking my head awake. “Jim arranged for me to meet this guy here.”

“That big guy, Karl?” She asked.

“I guess so. Anyway, Jim thinks it would be a thrill to watch another guy kinda get it on with me.” I admitted shyly.

“And you’re sure he picked that guy, Karl?” She asked.

“Yeah, why?”

“I don’t know. Karl comes in her every once in a while. He’s sort of a womanizer –been trying to get in my panties for months.”

“Well, I don’t know about that. Jim just said this tall guy, with a Steeler’s cap would be waiting for me…”

“So what’s your husband’s big plan?” She asked.

“I guess, if I like him, I’ll seduce him a little. Jim should be here anytime. Personally, I think once Jim sees me putting the make on Karl, he’ll be happy enough. I hope!” I said.

“Well, just be careful Laura. That Karl can get pretty carried away,” Jennifer warned. “Oh, one more thing. I liked kissing your big tits, but I REALLY loved the taste of your pussy!”

I gave her a “thank you” kiss and we went back into the bar.

“Gosh Laura, did you fall in? I thought maybe you got tired of me and left!” Said Karl, from the end of the bar.

I laughed and downed my second drink, “No way, Big Guy! Jen and I were just having a little girl talk.”

“Little more than girl talk, I’d say!” Karl remarked looking at my open blouse.

“Oh shit!” I muttered and started to button up.

“Now don’t go and do that! I like a woman with big hooters,” he smiled and yanked me onto the dance floor.

“Tell the truth now. You and that girl were smoochin’ in there, weren’t you?” He asked, running his calloused hands under my blouse and up my bare back.

“Why would you say such a thing, Karl. I’m not into that!” I said.

“Oh yeah? So, you like doing it with guys?”

“You bet!”

“Prove it!” He demanded.

“OK, I’ll prove it!” I said and took his head in my hands and kissed him.

Letting my fingers roam through his hair, I opened my mouth and deep-Frenched him. He shoved his tongue in my mouth and brought his hands around to fondle my tits. Circling his fat tongue with mine, I sucked it in hard. He gripped my melons like they were tomatoes, as I pulled back.

“How’s that for proof?” I winked at him.

“Not bad, but do I detect a taste of pussy?” He smirked.

“YOU FUCKER! After a world class kiss like that, and you still think I’m not into guys? The hell with you!” I yelled and jerked away from him.

He pulled me back and held me tight, while I tried to squirm away. The more I tried to escape, the more he tightened his grip.

“Let me go, you fucker. You hurting me!” I cried, pretending to be in pain.

“KARL! Let her go now!” Josh advised.

“Shut up Junior! This ain’t your affair. The lady has something to prove and she ain’t done it yet!”

“Karl, cut the shit out, or I’m calling the cops,” warned Josh.

“No Josh. Don’t call the police. I’m sure we can work this out,” I said to Josh, remembering Jim would be along soon.

“That’s right Josh. We’re gonna work this out aren’t we little lady?”

I nodded submissively.

He and took hold of my upper arm. With my blouse wide open, my tits swung to and fro, as he walked me back toward the restrooms. I gave a reassuring glance to Josh and Jennifer, as we neared the men’s room. Just then, directly in front of us, the front door opened. There was Jim followed by a tall black man in a Steeler’s cap. The four of us stopped dead in our tracks and starred at each other. Jim, of course, had no idea what was going down. I was suddenly and painfully aware that Karl was NOT the guy I was supposed to meet.

“Jesus Laura, what’s going on?” Asked a bewildered Jim, starring at my chest and Karl’s huge hand holding my arm.

“Oh not much, Honey. Just seems to be a case of mistaken identity. I’ll be alright,” I said, half-smiling at Jim and his friend.

“The little lady here has something to prove, then we’ll be right back. Is that OK with you?” Asked Karl, holding me hostage.

Jim was visibly shaken, but nodded just the same, as Karl pulled me into the restroom. Certain that Josh and Jennifer would explain things to my husband, I reconciled myself to my fate. Locking the door to the small restroom, Karl began to undress. Without a word, I followed his lead and stripped out of my clothes. With both of us standing there stark naked, the big man spoke.

“You’re being very cooperative –that’s nice. I’m really not such a bad guy, once you get to know me,” he said tugging on his sizable cock.

“I never said I didn’t like you, Karl. You just have to learn a little patience,” I said, taking hold of his meat. “See, I thought you were the guy my husband lined me up with tonight,” I said, stroking his fat cock.

“So, your old man likes watching guys fuck you, is that it?”

“Well, up until now, it has been one of his fantasies,” I remarked and sat down on the toilet seat.

I pulled him toward me and took his growing erection into my mouth. Fondling his balls, I began to suck him harder and faster. His hand massaged my tit, while I slobbered and sucked down his tool.

“Your husband is going to a lucky man tonight and you are gonna be one, sore lady,” he said and pulled my hair to suck him deeper.

As his cock pushed against the back of my throat, I felt it growing. I backed away and felt the girth of it expanding by the second. Soon my jaw opened to its fullest and my lips were stretched to the point of tearing. It was far too big for me to suck. I moaned in pain, as I slowly withdrew it from my arching mouth.

“Can’t handle it, can you?” Laughed Karl, as my pussy wet with desire for it. “Before the night’s over, you’ll be begging for it,” Karl said. “Until then, let’s give your husband an appetizer, shall we?”

He held my head still with one hand and jacked his mammoth meat with the other. I sucked on the bulbous head of it, until I tasted his precum. Circling my tongue around and around the head, I sensed he was ready to ejaculate.

“OK bitch, here it comes. I’m gonna fill that beautiful mouth of yours with my cum, but don’t you swallow!” He commanded and let go a long stream of white hot cum into my mouth. “Don’t you swallow bitch! Here comes some more,” he grunted and deposited another full wad of thick cum. As it leaked from the corners of my mouth, he used his cock to force it back in. My cheeks puffed out, as he shot one final stream down my forehead and nose. I looked up at him and moaned. We dressed, as he continued to remind me not to swallow his plentiful load. Unlocking the door, he walked me back to the bar.

-----------

“OK Laura, now give your hubby a nice big kiss,” Karl said.

I walked to Jim and let him get a nice look at what a cum-covered slut I had become. A mixture of abject apology and disgust shown on his face, as I took his head in my hands. He recoiled as I pulled his face nearer. Pressing my lips tight against his, he got a nice whiff of Karl’s fresh cum. I closed my eyes and edged my tongue past his tight lips. Letting out a familiar moan, I brushed my naked tits against him. Turning his head slightly, his mouth opened and I stuck my tongue in deeper. He pulled my body to his. Feeling the beginnings of his erection, I opened my mouth and released Karl’s entire load into his mouth. I saw his eyes open wide, as he dealt with the copious amount of starching white cream. The first taste of another man’s cum coming from his wife fully aroused him. I was so turned on watching him, I needed to be fucked right then.

Karl had gone to lock the front door during our kiss. When he returned I was in the middle of disrobing my husband. I sneaked a peak down the bar and saw Jennifer’s hand come out from under her skirt. Apparently Karl had seen what I had.

“Well now, what do we have here, a side show? Did that turn you on, little girl?” He asked Jennifer snidely.

“No! And I’m NOT a little girl!” She stated.

Karl went over to her and put his hand under her skirt. She pulled his hand away.

“Jennifer, you little slut. You’re not wearing panties!” Said Karl, licking his fingers. “I think you lied when you said Laura and Jim didn’t turn you on.”

“So what if I did?” Said Jennifer defiantly.

“Hmmm. There’s nothing wrong with being horny is there Laura?” Karl asked.

“No,” I answered politely and reached for Jim’s belt buckle.

“See Jen, Laura’s not shy about it, is she? Why she’s so horny, she’d fuck anything with a cock about now. Isn’t that so, Laura?”

I nodded, smiled and pulled Jim’s pants down.

“Why don’t you sit next to Laura over there and see how she deals with being so horny,” suggested Karl taking hold of her arm.

She ripped her arm from Karl’s grip and came to our table. She flopped down in a nearby chair, spread her legs open and slumped back like a pouting little girl.

“Karl, you better watch yourself,” reprimanded Josh.

“Oh don’t you worry Joshy-boy, there’s plenty of sweet pussy to go around tonight,” Karl laughed. “So Hubby, why not introduce us to your friend, who was supposed to pork your old lady?”

“His name is Steve, but I never said anything about him….” Said Jim, standing, while I stroked his erection.

“No, you didn’t. Excuse me. Laura told me that,” Karl explained. “Steve, why don’t you stand up and introduce yourself to Laura?”

The tall, silent black man stood up next to me, smiled and said hello. I reached up and shook his hand and returned his hello. He started to return to his seat, when Karl stopped him.

“So Steve, you got a thing for old white pussy?” Snickered Karl.

“She don’t look that old to me,” said Steve smiling down at me.

“Thank you,” I whispered up at him.

“Well Laura, what do you think of that? I think the man would fuck you, if you let him. Why don’t you see if he’s got anything worth fucking, hmmm?”

“Should I Honey?” I said, holding on to Jim’s cock and looking up at him.

Jim smiled and nodded, as I licked some precum from his cock tip. Still kneeling on the floor between the standing men and slumping Jennifer, I reached up to Steve’s belt and undid it. Tall Steve stood silently with his hands on his hips, while I undid his pants and pulled them to the floor. Jen nervously shifted in her chair, as I pulled Steve’s shorts down. Steve’s extra long black cock sprung to immediate attention and slapped the side of my face. I heard Jim slapping his meat behind me, as I ran my hand from the base of his tool to the pinkish head. Steve’s stunning ebony meat got Jen’s attention, as she secretly hid her hand under her skirt again.

“Josh, what are you doing?” Cried Jennifer, seeing her brother now standing between Jim and Steve.

“Just came over for a better look. Don’t want to miss the action, ya know!” Answered Josh staring down at my boobs.

“You want in this action too, Baby?” I asked.

Not waiting for his reply, I went to work on his pants. Josh’s young, delicious 8-inch cock had a delightful little turn in it. I reached and stroked it with my left hand, while I long-stroked Steve’s cock with the other.

“God Jen, so many delightful choices. What do you think?” I asked turning toward her.

Jen had seen enough, and was thoroughly aroused, perhaps at finally seeing her brother’s cock. She stood up and tore open her top and stepped out of her skirt. Her large rounded tits were every bit as big as mine, but her slim tummy, long legs and trimmed pussy were more than I could compete with.

“I think I’ll start with you,” she said to Jim and walked him over to the pool table.

I figured that was my cue to start sucking some cock, as I watched my husband first mount the pool table, then Jennifer. I soon discovered Josh’s cock was the perfect size for deep-throating, so I had him lay on the floor. Leaning over to suck Josh off, Steve entered my pussy from behind. Finally, my first real fucking in three weeks! I was on fire. Listening to Jim and Jen balling each other, only made me fuck harder. Steve thrust his long black rod into my cunt, so hard I kept losing my mouth-hold on Josh’s tool. Soon I felt Steve grip my ass and thrust in me one more time, filling my pussy with hot spunk. He pulled out his cock and I immediately mounted Josh on the floor.

Josh’s sweet cock wasn’t as long as Steve’s, but it was much thicker. This brought me to an unexpected orgasm. The longer I rode him, the more intense my climax became. When he reached up and pulled my tits I came again. Leaning down, I let him suck my boobs and slow-fuck me with long strokes. Pulling my ass cheeks apart, he inserted a finger in my asshole and I came again. In the middle of that orgasm, he turned us over, hoisted my legs up to his shoulders and deep fucked me. His stamina was remarkable, as he pounded my pussy relentlessly.

“Jesus Christ Josh! Are you ever going to cum? How long can you keep this up?” I said, running out of breath.

“I can go all night for you Laura, if you want?” He said, with a devilish grin. “Maybe you’d like to take a break?” He asked.

“That might be best, Baby. You’re wearin’ me out!” I exclaimed.

He let my legs down and slowly pulled his slick pussy-pleasing meat out. I sat up and looked over at the pool table, where Jen had just finished fucking Steve. Pulling myself up to the pool table. I could easily see she was nearly exhausted as I was.

“Hi, that felt top looks a little more comfortable than that fucking floor. May I join you?” I asked.

The long-legged brunette moved over to one side and motioned me to join her. “I’m afraid the slate on this thing isn’t much better, but welcome aboard,” She offered.

I climbed up and slid next to her. Facing each other, side by side, we fondled each other’s big melons and smiled. Josh went back to the bar to fix us some drinks, while Jim and Steve stood on either side of the pool table ogling us. Karl the instigator, sat uncharacteristically quiet on a barstool, surveying the situation.

“That husband of yours sure gives a good fuck,” whispered Jen.

“I know. Steve’s very good too, but he’s so fast,” I remarked.

“I know what you mean! So, how’s Josh?” She inquired, running her hand over my hip.

“Ummmm. Baby, your little brother is one mother-fucker! We must have done it for a good 20 minutes and he still didn’t get off. You should do him,” I suggested and ran my hand between her closed thighs.

“Me, do Josh? Are you crazy? That’s fucking incest! Beside, he’d never…” She started, as I shoved my hand closer to her trimmed bush.

“Never say never, Jennifer! If you’ve ever thought about what it would be like, now’s as good a time as any to try. Don’t you think?” I whispered and teased her pussy lips with my finger.

She let out a moan and raised her leg, allowing me full access to her pussy. Recalling how she had pleased me earlier, I swiveled around and started eating her out. A good portion of Jim and Steve’s cum oozed out of her tight hole, as I spread her lips apart. Frantically, I sucked and lapped up every last drop, until I was left with nothing but the taste of her sweet nectar. I heard Josh’s voice serving the drinks to the other men, and knew he was at Jennifer’s head of the table. Maneuvering Jen’s pelvis for a good tongue-fucking, I felt her hands pull my hips over her. We were locked in a lesbian 69, with my ass facing directly at Josh. Jen and I licked away at each other’s pussies, until we were both on the verge of orgasm.

“Dam, I wish that bartender would do his job, and serve me a stiff one!” I said loud enough for everyone’s ears.

“Yeah Josh, go on and give her a stiff one!” Laughed Jim, from my end of the table.

I briefly looked back to see Josh climbing on the pool table behind me. The next sensation I felt, besides Jen’s tongue on my slit, was Josh’s cock sliding down my ass crack and easily into my saturated pussy. He picked up right where he had left me, as his deep thrusts filled my cunt. I knew Jennifer had a wonderfully unobstructed, close-up view of her brother’s cock fucking me. It was only a matter of time, before she took advantage of the situation. Josh’s strokes began to slow, as Jen’s tongue teased the edge of my pussy and his dick simultaneously. He gave me one more deep thrust and with his hard cock throbbing inside me, I heard him let out a yell. Jennifer was sucking her brother’s balls.

“Oh GOD, I’m CUMING! I can’t stop it! God DAM!” Josh yelled and I felt the first shot of his hot semen in my pussy.

I lunged forward and sat up on my knees, while his cock erupted and fell out of my pussy.

“Take him Jen! TAKE HIM!” I commanded, and moved off of her.

His sister automatically shoved her brother’s shooting cock into her mouth. “NO, No, I can’t. It isn’t ri---“ Josh yelled, trying to stop the inevitable.

“Yes Josh, you can do it! She wants you. See!” I said, massaging his ass.

He finally looked down at his beautiful sister wantonly sucking his potent cock. Licking my fingers, I slowly inserted two of them into his rectum. Bending them slightly I stroked his prostate gland, which took him to the ultimate climax. There was no holding back now. His thick cock erupted stream after stream of starchy jism into Jen’s mouth, before she whipped it out and sprayed her massive tits with it. I was enjoying the whole erotic sight, when Jim and Steve took me by my arms and helped me off the pool table.

“What are you guys up to?” I laughed, knowing full well what they had in mind.

They led me to a back office with a sleeper sofa. They had pulled out the sleeper.

“Now this is more like it boys!” I said, appreciating their concern for my comfort.

I stretched out on the thin mattress, spread my legs and beckoned Steve to mount me. The thin black stud wasted no time in impaling my waiting pussy with his long rod.

“Take your time Sweety. There’s no rush. Now come here Jim and let me suck your cock, while you watch your friend fuck me.”