All Comments on 'The Island'

by miwoodsman

Sort by:
  • 4 Comments
AnonymousAnonymousalmost 11 years ago
5*

Spine tingling. Can't decide if if want more or if it is best left to the individual imagination. Well done.

SecondCircleSecondCirclealmost 11 years ago
Pretty damn good

I liked your descriptions and wordplay. This almost seems like an ominous prelude to something more. I think maybe it could have used a few more details to help develop the underlying story about the island and the shaman and all, but it does add a creepy air of mystery to it all.

The buildup around the house may have been distracting or unnecessary to some, but I thought incorporating the house and the eerie sights and misleading sounds within were still enough to build a little suspense to set the tone. I was sorta waiting for Rachel to hurt his junk, and for the sake of realism I'm glad you went that way.

I'm not sure if this will be continued, but if so I'd say your story will play itself out nicely. If not, just feed a few more explanatory details here and there in creative ways with your future projects. Good job. Keep going.

JBmanly50JBmanly50over 10 years ago
interesting

The suspense was good and the imagery very well done. This is the third story I have read by this author, starting with his most recent and working backwards. If I had started with this story, I doubt that I would have read another, but then I wouldn't have started with a horror story if I wanted to get off.

I plan on reading more because the first two were so captivating that I want to experience the same thrill that this author has engendered in me.

JBManly50

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 2 years ago

It should be "she has awakened". Geesh.

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous